RUGBY VS FOOTBALL HEAD INJURIES: COMPARING STATISTICS
By now, the National Football League (NFL) is as famous for its link to move trauma as it’s far for the elite athleticism and iconic American lifestyle it embodies. The devastating consequences that observe whilst the league does not take soccer head injuries seriously are raising many worries.
But now, American football has corporation in the controversy over head injuries and concussions. The International Rugby Board, primarily based in Ireland, is now host to a further heated debate. Concerns consist of protection guidelines of the sport, protections for players, and protocols for while a participant sustains a head harm.
Rugby vs soccer comparisons have truly existed for a while now. As is the case inside the NFL, the basis for the rugby head damage controversy was laid long in the past.
Establishing Head Injury Procedures
The spark that made the concussion issue capture fireplace inside the rugby global happened in July 2013. An Australian rugby participant collided violently with some other participant and stumbled off the sphere, visibly groggy and disoriented. To each person’s marvel, but, he returned to the sport only a few mins later.
Within the ones few minutes, the Australian player would have been administered an “off-subject cognitive test.” This is basically an audit of his signs and a quick test of his stability, reminiscence, and other capabilities. The International Rugby Board’s Procedures and Definitions require this check to be administered to gamers who get significantly injured at some stage in a game. The Procedures were drafted in 2011 in response to the developing variety of brain accidents sustained with the aid of gamers.
However, players are generally despatched returned to the sector within a couple of minutes after the cognitive check, notwithstanding the recommendations in the 2011 policies. These be aware that concussion signs and symptoms and signs can get worse through the years and that there isn’t a specific time restrict for determining the seriousness of a rugby concussion
Scottish rugby player Rory Lamont, who recently retired from the game directly because of this problem, has come to be the issue’s most outspoken critic. He stated the Australian player’s incident this manner:
“Everyone saw George wobbling his way off the field, honestly concussed, and then come back on. I know the protocols internal out and there may be no manner a player should be allowed to live at the pitch after a head knock. It’s madness. We are seeing reckless dismiss for players’ welfare right now.”
Which Is More Dangerous, Rugby or Football?
A lengthy-time reader, Tim, has been following our debate over the NFL and shifts our attention to some other touch game:
Count me among the many who’ve drifted away from the NFL, for all of the motives your readers have named: cheap patriotism, limitless games, nitpicky guidelines inconsistently enforced, CTE CTE CTE. This as a Pats fan who for most of the 2000s turned into riding a high.
I also be a part of reader Ed in switching my interest to rugby, in the limited manner I can with a basic cable agreement. The constant motion and first rate athleticism is one reason. An identical one is the “tradition of admire” that’s one among the sport’s foundations and most carefully guarded traditions. Players hardly ever deliberately hurt one another; once they do, they’re banned for months on end. Their infrequent scuffles are in the wrestling/bristling mode, no longer punching with venom.
And, crucially, the referee is The Law—and greater within the Solomonic than the Draconian mode. Disputes and fouls are resolved swiftly, fairly, and decisively. This supercut of the mythical Welsh ref Nigel Owens explains the appeal of this technique, versus the NFL’s limitless rulebook, a long way higher than I can.
With a word (“Christopher!”) he ends a debate complete-stop (and receives a schoolboy’s meek “Sorry, sir” from a mountain of a man). After breaking apart a huge scuffle, he has the captains call all the players to him, puts out the flames, and resets the order of play, all while preserving the game’s aggressive spirit firmly in the gamers’ arms:
I don’t need to make a large trouble of this, OK? But such things as that are not suitable in the sport. What came about here or what befell afterwards, I did now not see it. It ends there. Is that clean? You’re adults. You’ll be dealt with adore it so long as you behave find it irresistible. We’re going to move returned to the original penalty down there.
It’s of note that Owens is brazenly gay—and that each he and the sector’s best gamers are relaxed with that to the point that Owens even famously had a bit of fun with it. (The throw right here is supposed to come in perpendicular to the sideline. When it doesn’t…)
Rugby Head Injuries: The Grim Statistics
New Zealand journalist Ben Heather wrote a radical exposé of the difficulty. He spoke with current and retired rugby gamers about their reports with injuries and treatment. He noted the subsequent sobering statistics:
- About twelve hundred people suffer head injuries while gambling rugby each year.
- About -thirds of those injuries are both concussions or mind injuries.
- Rugby gamers are believed to play extra aggressively while the usage of scrum caps; however, research have shown these make no distinction for protective in opposition to head injuries.
- The figures do now not account for ongoing health problems, which can’t be immediately connected to rugby accidents.
- In general, more than 50,000 humans are trying to find medical attention for rugby injuries every year, costing about $60 million.
In 2011, the Auckland University of Technology compared the quantity of catastrophic incidents (i.E., resulting in paralysis or demise) in rugby with different sports between 1975 and 2005. It determined that besides for England, rugby incidents international showed four.6 catastrophic injuries for each one hundred,000 gamers annually.
Confronted with these facts, the response of a rugby professional became terse: “Rugby is not NFL football.”
How Does the NFL Compare? Rugby vs Football Concussion Statistics
Comparable NFL football concussion data appear like this:
Two hundred fourteen diagnosed concussions had been mentioned during the preseason and ordinary-season practices and games in the 2018 season.
However, one-0.33 of all NFL concussions are left off the injury document.
Half of the time, injured gamers go proper returned to gambling after an harm without missing a sport.
Since the NFL redrafted its injury-associated regulations in 2009, the league noticed a drop inside the quantity of gamers positioned on the harm document due to a concussion.
Week 12 of the NFL season is infamous for displaying a unexpected growth in concussions — specialists speculate it has to do with how small, steady blows to the head decrease the threshold for concussion occurrence.
The equal Auckland University of Technology report showed American football resulting in 1.Zero catastrophic incidents in keeping with every one hundred,000 players among 1975 and 2005. That’s greater than 75% fewer incidents than the index tallied in rugby.
The precedent set by using professional sports activities additionally has a chilling trickle-down effect on newbie, university, and kids’s sports. Amateur athletes will also be uncovered to concussion and brain harm risks, in particular in the event that they start young and enjoy blows to the head 12 months after yr.
Hire an Experienced Brain Injury Lawyer
One thing is apparent: both rugby and American soccer present clean risks of head and brain accidents. These may be debilitating and might result in lengthy-term medical conditions. Legal movement may be needed to help damage victims recover losses caused by a rugby or soccer head damage.
At the Brain Injury Law Center, we’ve got experience assisting sufferers of stressful mind damage reap the assets had to enhance their fine of lifestyles. We understand the different wishes associated with rugby vs football injuries. We are the most effective law firm inside the United States exclusively dedicated to representing mind injury sufferers, survivors, and their households.
Knowing how hard it become for Owens to accept himself as a gay guy makes his acceptance by way of and recognize from the sport’s excellent all the sweeter to behold.
So which game is extra risky? Rugby gamers put on some distance fewer pads, however it’s the ones pads that enable and embolden someone to hit any other player with extra pace and pressure—and it’s the sudden preventing, not the impact itself, that reasons the mind to crash into the inside of the skull, inflicting a concussion. Rugby players don’t wear helmets, however rather scrum caps, which do little more than save you cauliflower ear—even though again, it’s the helmet that lets in for more difficult hits and a tougher projectile, so helmets may be extra risky for players than caps.
Another primary contributing thing is that during football, offensive gamers are frequently looking backwards over their shoulder for the ball whilst the shielding player is in the front of them. There is no way for the offensive participant to see the hit coming and put together himself for the contact. In rugby, the ball ought to always be surpassed backwards, and the protection is in the front of the ball and much closer. The offensive player is able to see the ball coming and concurrently the tackler, permitting the participant to put together for touch.
So, are there any factors of rugby which can be extra risky than soccer? Football may additionally have a larger concussion crisis, and a better injury rate normal, however rugby has a distinct and severe problem: spinal accidents. As The Guardian notes, “In rugby it’s far spinal accidents from scrums that are the maximum risky (110 rugby gamers in Britain have been paralysed with the aid of playing the sport).” What’s a scrum exactly? This video vividly explains it and its perils:
Have you played soccer and rugby and can in my view attest to the unique dangers? Drop us an e mail. Carly performed at the least one of these sports activities:
I locate the condemnation of some other readers of the violence and “barbarism” of the NFL exciting. I played rugby at some stage in university and for awhile after commencement in a neighborhood adults’ league. There is something inherently, viscerally gratifying in setting my body on the road, in executing a strong address and bringing an opponent to the floor, or in stiff-arming a defender. It’s violent, however it’s a violence with regulations and a code of conduct. It can be deeply invigorating and empowering. I don’t suppose the damage the gamers inflict on every different is barbaric. (The exploitation of the players by using the proprietors, however … )
I ended up retiring from rugby after my 3rd concussion (I am a chronic klutz and became terrible at keeping the right form to lessen my threat for damage). Playing the sport became my choice to make, but I wasn’t assisting make millions of dollars for my coaches or any administrative team of workers. Providing support for the physical exchange-offs gamers make might seem to be basic attention given the sums they convey in. Given the money that floods the NFL, each player should be given the great feasible medical insurance for lifestyles—coverage that need to cover therapy and psychiatrists and anger control and couples’ counseling.
That, and they could take a few guidelines from rugby to hurry the game alongside a bit. It’s crazy how a soccer game drags out!
Update from every other reader, an expat from across the Pond:
I haven’t performed each soccer and rugby, but I have watched them plenty. To use a rather salty British expression (I’m an American living in Britain for the beyond 14 years, and in Ireland for the 3 years earlier than that), it’s bollocks to mention that rugby players who got down to injure opponents are routinely banned for lengthy stretches of time. Just seek YouTube for “Brian O’Driscoll spear address.” [A video of the O’Driscoll scandal is seen below, and here’s a video of “Top 5 Spear Tackles”—essentially picking a player up and dropping him on his head.]